The Boneyard



Return to Three-I Baseball 1919-1931.
in Evansville, Ind.
    -

by Jack Wettmarshausen

The 1920's have been referred to a s The Golden Age of Sports. Major league baseball was booming and the economy was good. Babe Ruth was becoming a legend and Yankee Stadium, dubbed "The House that Ruth Built", was opened in 1923 at the staggering cost of 2.5 million dollars. Ruth's offensive prowess at hitting homeruns would change the way the game of baseball was played in the major leagues. The Yankees became a dominant team. The news media covered the world of sports to a greater extent and sports figures were often portrayed as glamorous individuals performing heroic acts. Many of the famous baseball players of this era would later become enshrined in the Baseball Hall of Fame. Lou Gehrig, Walter Johnson, Pie Traynor, Rogers Hornsby, Ty Cobb, Tris Speaker and Grover Cleveland Alexander performed in the 1920's. It was an era that produced other great sports figures. Boxers Jack Dempsey and Gene Tunney were champions of this era. Tennis and golf were dominated by Bill Tilden and Bobby Jones respectively. In football Knute Rockne and Red Grange were achieving greatness. Athletes became larger than life to an admiring public, and reporters would often look the other way if these star athletes behaved in an unsavory manner out of the public arenas.

In Evansville, however, sports and baseball were not such a big glory-filled business. No great fortunes were made by the Evansville baseball owners, nor did the local teams dominate the Three-I League. Homeruns did not fly out of spacious Bosse Field with the same regularity as they did in Yankee Stadium with its short right field fence. The 1919-1931 era, which included the 1920's, was for Evansville baseball one of highs and lows, but mostly just getting by.

IN 1919 professional baseball returned to Evansville after a one-year absence. The Evansville Black Sox were owned and financed by the Evansville Baseball Fans Association. Stock was sold at ten dollars a share. The team was once again a member of the Three-I League, and all six teams were operated by fan associations. William Asplan was the club president and Johnny Nee was the playing manager. The team finished in third place with a winning record. Attendance went "over 30,000, and though no fortunes were made . . . a sufficient surplus remains to get a start in 1920".

The Evansville team dropped the Black Sox name in 1920 after the Black Sox scandal in the 1919 World Series; which featured Cincinnati outfielder, Edd Roush. The league expanded to eight teams and the Evas finished in second place. Near the end of the 1921 season it was rumored that the league would fold, as attendance in the western cities of Cedar Rapids, Rock Island, and Peoria was poor. The Evansville and Terre Haute teams complained of not making expenses on the western trips. A season ticket at Bosse Field cost twenty-seven dollars and fifty cents.

In 1924 the Evansville Baseball Fans Association had a new president, G. A. Beard, and the team a new name, The Evansville Pocketeers. The Evansville entry finished a strong second place in the standings and led the league in attendance with 81,000. The league was down to six teams yet league attendance was close to 300,000.

The following year, 1925, saw the Three-I League adopt the practice of assigning numbers to the players' jerseys to enable the fans to more easily identify the players. Though the club finished in third place with a winning record, the attendance fell dangerously low. Even though attendance was good the previous year, the Fans Association lost six thousand dollars the last four years of operation and was in financial trouble.

A tragic event occurred that same year at Bosse Field. A twenty-three year old pitcher for the opposing Decatur, Illinois team, Louis Chedo, was hit in the head by a pitched ball thrown by the Evansville hurler, Elmer Gray. Chedo walked off the field and was examined at a local doctor's office and sent to his room at the Vendome Hotel. Although "he had lost his power of speech, Chedo seemed to be suffering little ill effects from the blow". Later that night, he was taken to St. Mary's Hospital where he died of a ruptured artery in the brain. Witnesses said Chedo appeared to duck into the pitch, and the Evansville pitcher, Gray, was not accused of throwing at the unfortunate player.

Starting in 1926 the Evansville team was known as the Hubs. The manager position changed again and the team finished in fifth place. The attendance was one of the best in club history, over 71,000. In 1927 the Hubs finished in last place and lost $20,000 on the year.

In 1928 the Hubs were purchased by Bob Coleman, acting as an agent of the Detroit Tigers. Coleman was president and manager of the Hubs. Major league ownership was heralded as the solution for the minor leagues. By 1929, of the eight teams in the Three-I League, only three were locally owned, those being Bloomington, Ill., Decatur, Ill., and Springfield, Ill. Still, the Hubs lost $12,000 in 1928 in a split-season caused by poor attendance due to weather and the large early lead in the standings of the Terre Haute team.

The first night game at Bosse Field took place on August 12, 1931. The Hubs lost 7-6 before a crowd of 3,041. The field was reportedly well-lit except that left and center fields were somewhat hazy. There were fourteen night games that year and they drew 21,500 fans for those fourteen night games, an average crowd of 1,535 per game. Altogether the Hubs drew about 50,000 fans in 1931.

Coleman could not get the Evansville franchise to show a profit, despite leading the league in attendance in 1929. The early 1930's depression years were lean ones for the minor leagues. After the 1929 season there were twenty-five minor leagues in operation; by 1931 the number had fallen to sixteen. The Board of Education had spend $50,000 on improvements to Bosse Field in 1930 and raised the rent three hundred dollars for the year. Coleman threatened to move the franchise to another city that year, but came back in 1931. After the 1931 season, Coleman resigned his position as president and manager and the team was put up for sale by Detroit for $5,000. A group made up of G. A. Beard, Punch Knoll and Hub's business manager, Gil Ellis, showed interest in buying the team, but the transaction was never completed. The following year, 1932, the team was playing in Decatur, Illinois, still owned by Detroit and managed by Bob Coleman. The Decatur team folded during the 1932 season and the league suspended operations shortly afterward.

Under Detroit and Coleman the emphasis was put on developing good young talent, instead of aging veterans employed by the previous owners. Whitlow Wyatt was the strikeout leader of the league in 1928. He led the league in strikeouts and games won in 1929 with twenty-two wins before moving to Detroit. Tommy Bridges led the league in strikeouts in 1930 and once recorded twenty strikeouts in one game before joining Detroit. Others who played in Evansville before promotion to the major leagues include Hall of Famers Hank Greenberg and Chuck Klein, John Stone, the Walker brothers, Hum and Gerald, Pete Fox and pitchers L. D. Hamlin and Chief Hogsett.



The Boneyard Invites Your Comments

Back to The Boneyard